a critique of gandhi on christianity

a critique of gandhi on christianity插图

Christology as dogma
The central issue in Gandhi’s criticism of Christianity isChristology as dogma; the resolution of Gandhi’s criticism is through orthopraxis,or right action,p 98. Christology can be seen from two points of view,descriptive and prescriptive.

Was Gandhi right about Christian missionaries in India?

In many ways Gandhi was right, the intense proselytization by Christian missionaries in India through force and allurement forced him to make many scathing statements against Christian missionaries, which several times inspired them to retrospect and change the way of approach in ‘Evangelism’. “If Jesus came to earth again.

What did Gandhi think about the atonement?

Gandhi saw Jesus’ atonement, which (in his mind) should have been an example for imitation, flouted by many Christians in their understanding of it as substitution and wasted on those who did not change their lives… He said ‘I rebel against orthodox Christianity’, p 95.

What is the central issue in Gandhi’s criticism of Christianity?

The central issue in Gandhi’s criticism of Christianity is Christology as dogma; the resolution of Gandhi’s criticism is through orthopraxis, or right action, p 98. Christology can be seen from two points of view, descriptive and prescriptive.

Did Gandhi reject Christ?

When the missionary E. Stanley Jones met with Gandhi he asked him, “Mr. Gandhi, though you quote the words of Christ often, why is that you appear to so adamantly reject becoming his follower?” Gandhi replied, “Oh, I don’t reject Christ.

What is Gandhi’s central issue in his criticism of Christianity?

The central issue in Gandhi’s criticism of Christianity is Christology as dogma; the resolution of Gandhi’s criticism is through orthopraxis, or right action, p 98. Christology can be seen from two points of view, descriptive and prescriptive.

What is the difference between Gandhi’s beliefs and Christianity?

An examination of Gandhi on Christianity will demonstrate, however, that the difference between Gandhi’s beliefs (including his beliefs about Christianity) and Christianity is a fundamental one. It will also demonstrate that Gandhi’s real interest in Christianity was political, he hoped to find support for pacifism in it.

What did Gandhi say about Jesus?

Gandhi said that Jesus was near perfect but not as perfect as God , p 26; that he had psychic powers and that his miracles were magic, p 27. Gandhi sees Jesus as an example, a rule of life, p 27. He says "Jesus represents not a person, but the principle of nonviolence ", p 46. The central issue in Gandhi’s criticism of Christianity is Christology as …

What is Gandhi’s idea?

Gandhi’s idea is rooted in the Eastern, and New Age, denial of the mind.") There is an interesting statement on p 44. In response to the Christian claim that God sometimes spoke through prophets using words, Gandhi admits that "I am up against a solid wall of Christian opinion". How true, how true.

What is the central element of the Christian faith?

The central element in the Christian faith is atonement; God sent his Son to save us by his substitutionary death (atonement) (John 3:16; 2 Cor. 5:21). "Good" works add nothing to our salvation; we are saved through faith alone and even this faith is a gift from God.

What is Gandhi’s message in the Bible?

Sadly, the central message of the Bible, the Gospel (I Cor. 15:1-4), is lost on Gandhi. He proposes the oldest counterfeit of all, self-salvation. Self salvation results from two misconceptions: an underestimation of God’s absolute holiness, and an overestimation of mankind’s goodness.

What is Gandhi’s right belief?

Right belief is critical. Gandhi’s beliefs represent a complete reinterpretation of the New Testament message and a redefinition of Christianity, and they mirror Gandhi’s own biases. (I have given just a sampling of the many possible Bible references to establish each point.)

What did Gandhi do to influence the way of evangelism?

In many ways Gandhi was right, the intense proselytization by Christian missionaries in India through force and allurement forced him to make many scathing statements against Christian missionaries, which several times inspired them to retrospect and change the way of approach in ‘Evangelism’ .

What happened to Gandhi after he decided to attend the church service in South Africa?

After deciding to attend the church service in South Africa, he came across a racial barrier, the church barred his way at the door. “Where do you think you’re going, kaffir?” an English man asked Gandhi in a belligerent tone. Gandhi replied, “I’d like to attend worship here.” The church elder snarled at him, “There’s no room for kaffirs in this church. Get out of here or I’ll have my assistants throw you down the steps.” This infamous incident forced Gandhi to never again consider being a Christian, but rather adopt what he found in Christianity and its founder Jesus Christ.

How did Gandhi respond to the question of love?

Second, practice it without adulterating it or toning it down. Third, emphasize love and make it your working force, for love is central in Christianity.

Why is Gandhi considered a leader?

For sure this great man is one of the most respected leaders of modern history not only because of how he lived his life, but also because of his ideals and his message to the people. Although a Hindu, Gandhi had a very close connection with Christianity and admired Jesus very much, often quoting from his favorite ‘Sermon on the Mount’ (Mathew 5, 6 &7). When the missionary E. Stanley Jones met with Gandhi he asked him, “Mr. Gandhi, though you quote the words of Christ often, why is that you appear to so adamantly reject becoming his follower?”

What would have happened if not for Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi?

R. Dkhar. If not for Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, the Indian Independence struggle would have taken longer with more bloodshed, division and war. When senior leaders of the Hindu political groups urged Gandhi to respond to ‘violence with violence’ and ‘sword with sword’, he opposed it and insisted and exhorted them to follow the path …

What did Gandhi study?

Apart from being attached with the Christian faith, he intently studied the Bible and the teachings of Jesus, and was also seriously exploring becoming a Christian, which led him to his discovery of a small church gathering in his locality. These strongly entrenched Biblical teachings have always acted a panacea to many of India’s problems during its freedom struggle.

Who killed Gandhi in India?

Gandhi was shot in Birla House compound in New Delhi at the age of 78. He was killed by Nathuram Godse, who had opposed Gandhi’s views on the Partition of India. Hence his 72 nd death anniversary on January 30, 2020 is commemorated in the country as Martyrs Day. Continue Reading.

What did Gandhi read?

13 Gandhi agreed and began reading the Bible. Parts of the Old Testament "repelled" him, but the ‘Sermon on the Mount’ in the New Testament, "went straight to my heart" 14 and he "tried to unify the teaching of the Gita, the ‘Light of Asia’ and the Sermon on the Mount.". 15 Subsequently he wrote "The New Testament gave me comfort and boundless joy, …

What does Gandhi mean by "Jesus means to me"?

Gandhi’s great respect for Christ and the extent to which he drew inspiration from him are revealed in his following statements: "What does Jesus mean to me? To me, he was one of the greatest teachers humanity has ever had." 6 "Jesus lived and died in vain if He did not teach us to regulate the whole of life by the eternal law of love. ". 7

What does conversion mean?

Conversion should mean a definite giving up of the evil of the old, adoption of all the good of the new and a scrupulous avoidance of everything evil in the new. Conversion therefore should mean a life of greater dedication to one’s own country, greater surrender to God, greater self purification.". 24.

What did Jesus say about wisdom coming out of the mouth of babes?

In enunciating his educational ideas he wrote "Jesus never uttered a loftier or a grander Truth than when he said that wisdom cometh out of the mouth of babes. I believe it . If we are to reach real peace in this world and if we are to carry on real war against war, we shall have to begin with the children.". 18.

What was Gandhi’s approach to religion?

Though a deeply devout Hindu, Gandhi’s basic approach to all religions was ’sarvadharma samabhav’ (equal respect for all religions). For him all religions had equal status and were different paths to the same goal of achieving union with the Divine. His religion was that "which transcends Hinduism, which changes one’s very nature, …

How long did the Wellington Convention last?

About it he wrote " The convention lasted for three days. I could appreciate the devoutness of those who attended it.

What was Gandhi’s contribution to Christianity?

Gandhi, Christ and Christianity. Gandhi’s fundamental contribution in the field of religion was to give primacy to Truth and rationality rather than conformity to traditional practices.

What were Gandhi’s views on Christianity?

As discussed throughout this article, Gandhi’s views on Christianity and Islam were amenable to a defined set of ‘moral’ and ‘ethical’ standards that were open to criticism from both allies and critics. This has been explored vis-à-vis his views on the stoning of Ahmadiya Muslims in Afghanistan as well as his concerns with mass proselytization of the more ‘vulnerable’ sections of society by the Christian missionaries. Gandhi was always willing to offer assistance to communities who required it, as seen in the instance of the Khilafat movement, and at the same time was quick to dismiss claims of one particular religion’s all-encompassing superiority as seen in his discourse with the Christian missionaries.

What did Gandhi admire most about Jesus Christ?

From the pre-existing biographical accounts, it has already been established that Gandhi had a deep-seated admiration for the personality of Jesus Christ. This profound admiration was imbibed in Gandhi during his education in England – when a friend recommended the Old Testament to him during his preparation for the bar examination. The text of the Old Testament had a positive influence on the Mahatma who found Christ extremely endearing and regarded him as one of the greatest mentors of humanity. [xv] However, he was unable to sympathise with the insistence of the Christian community who asserted the superiority of their religion over other schools of thought. This presumption of superiority rested in the notion that Jesus Christ was the only individual who was ‘perfect in the eyes of the Almighty’. However, Gandhi was critical of this stance, one that was frequently contended by the missionaries, in his assertion that claiming perfection would invariably deny the Almighty’s supremacy to human beings. [xvi] He disregarded the claims of perfection and believed that ‘a human being’s nature could be honed to perfection and that Christ had nearly attained this perfection, although not in entirety’ . [xvii]

What was Gandhi’s legacy?

In the 21 st century, most scholarly work that analyses the legacy left behind by Mahatma Gandhi largely consists of his early days as a lawyer, his rise to prominence as an ‘anti-colonial nationalist’, and his ethics employed in leading the largest political non-violent struggle against our former colonial rulers, that serves as a source of inspiration and learning for the world. [i] As a self-proclaimed orthodox Hindu, it was no surprise that religion played an important role in shaping Gandhi’s thoughts and ideas. These were often reflected in his political movements, where he engaged in the earnest critique of various religious denominations and their belief systems.

Was Gandhi involved in the Khilafat movement?

Having returned to India after several years abroad, Gandhi was quick to involve himself in the events of the Khilafat movement bringing with him an impressive background, involving nearly two decades worth of intensive governmental activity, during which he maintained a strong affiliation with the expatriate Indian Muslim community. [iv] Most of Gandhi’s acquaintances, who were deeply involved in the political sphere, considered the entire Khilafat movement to be a ‘ religious affair’ that was not important for the Indian subcontinent and its citizens. [v] As a result, Gandhi received unrelenting bouts of disparagement for lending his assistance to the movement. Many believed that lending support to the movement was inherently perilous as it could plausibly contribute to the upsurge of ‘religious fanaticism’ and ‘pan-Islamism’ within the country. [vi]

What did Gandhi hear from his Christian friends?

What Gandhi heard from his “Christian friends” in his youth was not true Christianity. It was not the entire gospel. Paul, on the other hand, writes about true Christianity in Romans 6:11-12: “Likewise you also, reckon yourselves to be dead indeed to sin, but alive to God in Christ Jesus our Lord.

What is Mahatma Gandhi’s lifelong search for the truth?

What is perhaps not so well known is this man’s lifelong search for the truth. In his writings he always searches for three main virtues: Truth, love and purity (Satya, …

What does it mean when Jesus says he is tempted in all points?

It is written about Jesus that He was “tempted in all points as we are, yet without sin”, which proves that it is totally possible for a human to come to victory over sin. We are encouraged to approach Him to find help and grace so that we can win the same victory. (Hebrews 4:15-16)

Did Gandhi have a Hindu faith?

Gandhi grew up as a Hindu, and he confessed this faith his entire life. He spent several years in England while studying the law, and later moved to South Africa for some years, where he worked as a lawyer. He met and conversed with many believing Christians in these countries, particularly in South Africa. He listened to these people with an upright mind, one that was seeking the truth without prejudice, and also read many books about the Christian faith which were available to him.

Was Gandhi a Christian?

Gandhi was never converted to the Christian faith. Like Socrates before him, he chose instead to listen to the “inner voice.” He followed a political career, and writes that he made it his religion to serve people.

Who wrote "And the brother proved as good as his word"?

K. Gandhi , 1927-29).