a debate between postmodernism ethics and christianity

a debate between postmodernism ethics and christianity插图

The ideas of Christianity and of postmodernism, respectively, areincompatible and irreconcilable. The struggle for the ascendancy of postmodernism (and its precursors), which struggle has dramatically increased in scope and intensity from about the mid-twentieth century, constitutes a major ideological war against Christianity.

What does postmodernism have against Christianity?

Postmodernism doesn’t like Christianity. It doesn’t like Christianity to predicate things about reality: that there’s a God, He brought this world into being; he controls it under His Providence; one day He’s going to bring it to an end and usher in the new heavens and the new earth.

Is morality postmodern or modern?

Modernism was characterized by a majority of people holding firmly to a foundational Judeo-Christian worldview — but in a pluralistic and relative postmodern period, morality is driven by a desire to let individuals determine right and wrong based on personal preferences and a spirit of freedom for individual choices.

What is the net cultural effect of postmodern philosophy?

The net cultural effect of postmodern philosophy is a culture deeply suspicious of any kind of truth claims, whether “legitimated by universal reason” or not. To present the Christian faith as truth to a postmodern world is a massive challenge.

What is the difference between postmodernism and premodernism?

So the Premodern person says ethics is based on the character of the transcendent God. The Modern person says, “No, you learn what’s right and wrong from human reason and experience.” The Postmodern man says, “Right and wrong? We make that up as we go along!” VIII.

What is the categorical imperative?

On the other hand, in order to justify such a claim, postmodernism requires the wholesale rejection of what has been called the ‘categorical imperative’: "a moral obligation or command that is unconditionally and universally binding".

What is the last sentence of Dunning’s disclaimer?

In the context of his own words, his disclaimer can only mean that ’there is truth’-but only for each individual in his or her own mind; otherwise , there is no such thing as truth that can be objectively known, much less shared with anyone else.

Is postmodernism antithetical to Christianity?

It should be clear to the reader that postmodernism is antithetical not only to the precepts and spirit of Christianity but, explicitly and most importantly, to the written Word of God . By far the most pernicious aspect of postmodernism is its rejection of the veracity and authority of God’s Word.

Is postmodernism understood?

While it seems the meaning of the word postmodernism is not well understood by most people, yet the ideas it embodies have profoundly affected an entire generation, in a host of ways that typically aren ‘t seen for their connection to post modern beliefs.


Postmodernist believe that morality comes by the greater demand of the people, thus meaning that the people decide what’s right and what’s wrong not God. Christian on the other hand believes in a contrasting worldview; reason for maintain goodness.

Summary of Postmodernism

Postmodernist establishes man as the final authority, truth maker, this leads man to a godless place questioning all theism metanarratives and denying the one God given single truth.

Source of Ultimate Authority in Postmodernism

The source of ultimate authority in the postmodern worldview is the human mind or where a human mind is promoted. Because there is no such thing as final truth, there is a lack of an objective source of authority.

Ultimate Reality in Postmodernism

Ultimate reality for Postmodernism can be viewed through the lens of religion, not all postmodernist are atheist, so they too can define and understand through natural science (or materialism), that a higher being could potentially exist.

Source of Morality

Postmodernism source of morality is gathered from ethical systems in atheism, naturalism, and evolution. They believe there is no authority beyond the self. Postmodernist source various morals via little narratives, because there is no grand narrative instructing them on what is real and how to behave.

Evaluation of Postmodernism

For the purpose of evaluating this worldview, I will be using Groothuis criteria for test and evaluating worldviews. Groothuis illustrates that these criteria are universal and can be used to evaluate any worldview.

Christian Alternative

Christians believe that there is only one truth and that’s Jesus Christ. Without the crucifixion and the resurrection of the Son, born from a virgin mother, sent to the world as a living sacrifice from the Father, there is no need for this belief system. The proof of change is also the compass pointing to true North.

How does postmodernism affect humanity?

Rather than serving to restrain the darker aspects of fallen human nature and, instead, inspire men and women to nobler attitudes and conduct, postmodernism propels fallen humanity headlong towards the rapidly approaching Apocalypse. The self-destructiveness of postmodernism is inherently self-limiting; it cannot sustain human cohabitation, much less civil human society. But that thought is of little comfort. For, until its eventual demise, this ideology of madness no doubt will yet bring unspeakable suffering to mankind.

What is postmodernism?

Postmodernism denies there is truth, while insisting that its own claims are true. It rejects all authority but its own. It insists that words and propositions have no certain meaning, while using words and propositions to convey the meaning of postmodernism (and to attempt to overthrow the meaning of everything else).

Why are children trained by jihadists?

While children abroad are being trained by jihadists to be martyrs for the cause of Allah, children in the United States-untold millions of them-are being trained by postmodern multiculturalists to live and die for the cause of the New World Order. And while Americans are fighting ‘terrorism’ across the sea, a less visible-but no less lethal-war is being waged on Main Street, USA: a spiritual war-foremost, for the meaning, as well as for the dissemination of the Gospel of Jesus Christ; which is a war for the soul of this nation, and for the souls of our children.

Do postmodernists suppose that anarchy is preferable to civil society?

Do postmodernists suppose that anarchy is preferable to civil society? No doubt some postmodernist would answer, "That depends on what you mean by ‘civil’". (This line of inquiry, of course, hints at a wider critique of leftist ideologies; which, critique, would add much to prove the devil’s influence on postmodernism, but is beyond the scope of this series.)

What is the net cultural effect of postmodernism?

The net cultural effect of postmodern philosophy is a culture deeply suspicious of any kind of truth claims, whether “legitimated by universal reason” or not. To present the Christian faith as truth to a postmodern world is a massive challenge. But understanding postmodernism in more depth can help us to find better ways of responding than simply repeating arguments for objective truth more loudly.

What is Opportunity 2?

Opportunity 2: a hunger for community and authenticity. I asked earlier how we should witness to our faith if not by trying to “prove” Christianity by appeal to universal reason.

Who said postmodernism is the outworking of mistakes in Christian theology?

In A Better Hope, Stanley Hauerwas made the provocative claim that “Postmodernism is the outworking of mistakes in Christian theology correlative to the attempt to make Christianity ‘true’ apart from faithful witness.” Postmodernism has the potential to be a catalyst to spur the Church into recovering its mission of being Christ to the world.

Is postmodernism more open to spirituality than modernism?

Opportunity 1: a new openness to spirituality Postmoderns tend to be much more open to the spiritual than moderns – Alister McGrath observed in Evangelicalism and the Future of Christianity that “the claustrophobic and restrictive strait-jacket placed on Western Christianity by rationalism has gone”. That’s only partly true – the so-called “New Atheism” tends to be stridently modernistic. But many people are dissatisfied with modernity’s inability to satisfy their need for spiritual meaning and purpose.

Is postmodernism a negative thing?

On the negative side, postmodernism brings the danger of neglecting the rational, and this apparent unity often comes out of a doctrina l apathy, rather than us being any better at dealing with disagreements. Are we following Ephesians 4:15 by “speaking the truth in love, growing up into Christ our head,” or are we just “not speaking anything contentious in apathy”?

What does postmodernism reject?

Postmodernism rejects modernism’s autonomous individualism and all that follows from it. Rather than seeing humanity as an ocean of individuals, postmodernists think of humans as "social constructs.". We do not exist or think independently of the community with which we identify.

What did modernists believe?

Naively, postmodernists charge, modernists assumed that the mind was a "mirror of nature," meaning that our perceptions of reality actually correspond to the way the world is. From this presumption, modernists built a culture that exalted technological achievement and mastery over the natural order.

What do postmodernists say about the modern age?

Postmodernists say that the idols of autonomous reason and technological proliferation have brought the modern age to the brink of disaster. The "myth of progress" ends up in a nightmare of violence, both for marginalized people and for the earth. Enter postmodernism.

What does the pretense of objective truth do to violence?

Postmodernists hold that the pretense of objective truth always does violence by excluding other voices (regarding other world views to be invalid), and marginalizing the vulnerable by scripting them out of the story. Truth claims, we are told, are essentially tools to legitimate power.

What is the point of postmodernism?

Consequently, postmodernists reject the possibility of objective truth. Reality itself turns out to be a "social construct" or paradigm.

What is the new way of thinking?

The new way of thinking (as opposed to modernism: the old way of thinking). Postmodernism is the cultural worldview that now penetrates and owns our society. This worldview deeply values the following: spirituality, pluralism, the experiential, relativity, altruism, community, creativity, the arts, environmentalism, globality, holism, …

What is the argument that every time someone claims to be in possession of the truth (especially religious truth), it ends up?

The argument is that every time somebody claims to be in possession of the truth (especially religious truth), it ends up repressing people. So its best to make no claims to truth at all. Rejecting objective truth is the cornerstone of postmodernism.


In the social sphere, postmodernism corresponds to the society of consumption and mass media, the main characteristics of which look amorphous, blurred, and indefinite. It does not have a clearly defined socio-class structure. The level of consumption is the main criterion of division into social strata.

Evaluation of the Worldview

In general, the worldview of a postmodern person can be defined as neo-fatalism. Its peculiarity is that a person no longer perceives oneself as the master of one`s destiny, who relies on oneself in everything, owes everyone to oneself.

Evaluation of Christianity

Speaking of the Christian worldview as the only true opposition to the postmodern one, people should understand its basic principles, ideas, and concepts. To begin with, one should note that the central component of the Christian worldview is morality`s concept, which is fundamentally different from the basic ideologies of postmodernism.

Defense of Christianity

Postmodernists insist that the truth is relative in defense of the principals of morality. They argue that the truth must be material, and recognize financial success, and convenience among the basic values. In contrast to them, Christians consider their religion as an embodiment of true humanity.


In conclusion, one should note once again: Postmodernism shows people that everything should be perceived positively and that there are no ideologies, and Christianity, on the contrary, teaches people to believe in God and honor him, which makes it more meaningful and trustworthy religion.

How has postmodernism impacted science?

Secondly, what kind of impact has Postmodernism made on science itself? Well, you know, it’s hard to change 2 + 2 = 4. But the philosophy of science has been profoundly impacted by Postmodernism. Postmodernists have worked very hard to deny that there is any known or knowable connection between what we think and say and what is actually out there in the world. The Postmodernist says there is no proof that the rules of science are good, other than the consensus extended to those rules by the experts. To which one scientist has responded, “Fine. Step out that tenth story window and tell me that when you hit the bottom! You know, you can’t ignore that law of reality, but Postmodernism is even trying to change the way we do science today.

What does "postmodern" mean?

And he defined Postmodern as meaning ‘ incredulity toward metanarratives .’. That means that Postmodernism doesn’t like someone to tell you a comprehensive, explanatory story for the totality of the world as it is. In other words, Postmodernism doesn’t like a worldview.

What did the premodern man say about human beings?

The Premodern man said that human beings were created in the image of God, and therefore, had a central dignity. The Modern man said no, human beings are the product of their DNA template and unplanned sequences of evolution and survival of the fittest. [Postmodern] man says, “No, no, no–it’s not that glorious.

What does Paul say about postmodernism?

And if you are a Christian and you imbibe part of the truths of Postmodernism, it can cripple your ability to live the Christian life, because Paul said in Romans 12:1, 2 that we are not to be conformed to this world, but we are to be transformed by the renewing of our minds.

What is the only kind of truth there is?

Just stories. Truth is whatever we can get our community to agree on. And our story is as true as any other story will ever be. So the only kind of truth there is, is pragmatic truth.

What is the name of the university in Handsome State University?

And it’s a story account of a young evangelical Christian who leaves a Bible church and goes off to a fictitious state university called Handsome State University, which is a thinly veiled reference to the University of California at Berkley, otherwise known as “the nut house.”.

Why are we arguing about gender inclusive language?

Do you ever wonder why we are arguing now about gender-inclusive language? It’s because people have decided that language is all there is–there’s no truth behind it–language is the way you impose your worldview. They don’t like the old worldview, so they changed the language to bring about a new worldview. That’s why we’re arguing, for instance, about gender-inclusive language. With Postmodernism, there is no purely objective knowledge, no truth of correspondence; only stories, stories which, when they are believed, give the storyteller power over others.

What is postmodernism and the Church?

Postmodernism and the Church. Since the mid 20th century (1950-60’s), a system that denies absolutes and. objectivity has emerged into our society. It has brought every established tradition and metanarrative into subject.

What are the influences of postmodernism?

Postmodernism has become an influence across the board: theology, art, culture, architecture, society, film, technology, and economics. Traditional, social, art, and cultural beliefs are discarded and reinterpreted in relativistic terms. Unfortunately this includes the traditional teachings of the church based on Scripture.

What are some examples of postmodern thought?

An example of postmodern thought would be the validation of homosexuality as an equally legitimate sexual expression over and against the Judeo-Christian ethic of heterosexuality. Also, that gay marriage is an equally legitimate union over and against the Judeo-Christian ethic of marriage between a man and woman.

What is moral relativism?

Moral/ethical relativism – All morals are relative to the social group within which they are constructed.

Is postmodernism tolerated?

This is a worldwide movement but predominantly here in America where pluralism and relativism are rampant. The only thing by the postmodernist not tolerated is intolerance. Tolerance is king to the postmodernist who says, My truth is different from your truth so don’t judge me with your outdated morals. Such thought process by the spiritually dead is all too common.

Has postmodernism entered the church?

Postmodernism has entered the church. I’m sure it is clear to see by now that the church hasn’t escaped from postmodernism. In America, apostasy has reared its ugly head in the church. The church is under attack and one of the enemy’s weapons is postmodernism.

Is the postmodern movement ironic?

The postmodern movement is full of irony. How? The absolute truth that the postmodernists refute, which is the Scriptures, they confirm.